
MONTGOMERY | The Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals has upheld the manslaughter conviction of former Tiny Tigers Daycare employee Payton Nicole Gann in the 2022 death of four-month-old Autumn Rose Wells at the Red Bay childcare facility, rejecting arguments that trial errors warranted a new trial.
In a memorandum decision released June 18, the court, in a unanimous decision, affirmed a Franklin County Circuit Court judgment that found Gann guilty of manslaughter in the death of Wells, who died March 9, 2022, while in the care of employees at Tiny Tigers Daycare.
Gann was originally indicted on charges of manslaughter and false reporting to law enforcement. During her trial, she pleaded guilty to the false-reporting charge. A jury later convicted her of manslaughter. She was sentenced to 20 years in prison for the manslaughter conviction, split to serve five years in prison followed by five years of supervised probation. She also received a 12-month jail sentence for false reporting, with the sentences ordered to run consecutively.
Among the issues raised on appeal were claims related to forged childcare-training certificates that surfaced on the last day of the trial. The discovery that the certificates were fake later resulted in new charges being levied against former owner Angelene Chamblee.
According to the court’s opinion, Wells was placed in Gann’s infant room on the morning of March 9, 2022. Testimony at trial showed the child was wrapped in a blanket and placed on a “Boppy” nursing pillow for a nap. Another daycare worker later found the infant unresponsive shortly before 1 p.m. and summoned help. The child was transported to Red Bay Hospital, where she was pronounced dead.
A state medical examiner testified that the infant’s death was “undetermined” due to the atypical sleep environment. The opinion states that placement on the Boppy pillow created a position that could compromise breathing and that the infant was later found sleeping on her stomach, unattended, with her head covered by a blanket.
The appeal centered largely on training certificates that had been introduced during the trial. The certificates appeared to show Gann had completed required childcare training courses. During the trial, however, prosecutors learned from Child Care Central, the company that maintained the training records, that the certificates were not valid and had not been issued by the organization. The state then informed the court and defense attorneys that the certificates were forged.
Gann argued on appeal that prosecutors violated the requirements of the U.S. Supreme Court’s Brady v. Maryland decision by failing to disclose information concerning the certificates before trial. She also argued the circuit court should have declared a mistrial, allowed her to reopen her case, and given a requested jury instruction after the forged documents were discovered.
The Court of Criminal Appeals rejected those arguments.
The court found that Gann’s attorneys did not make a timely objection to the certificates when they were introduced at trial and therefore failed to preserve the Brady claim for appellate review. The judges also concluded that prosecutors did not know the certificates were forged until trial was underway and notified both the defense and the court as soon as the information was confirmed.
Regarding the request for a mistrial, the appellate court noted that trial judge Brian Hamilton instead instructed jurors that the certificates were invalid, withdrew them from evidence and informed jurors that Gann had not received the training reflected in those documents. The appeals court ruled that the trial court acted within its discretion in denying a mistrial and later denying a motion for a new trial.
The court also found that Gann agreed to the stipulation that was read to jurors concerning the forged certificates and did not preserve objections related to reopening the case or to the jury instructions she later challenged on appeal.











