RED BAY | City Council members voiced concerns over hiring and firing decisions Mayor Charlene Fancher has made during a special called council meeting on Thursday, Oct. 12. While the meeting will not change those decisions and the legality isn’t in question, the Council is looking to establish clearer lines of what is and isn’t considered an officer of the city, and will seek to have more say over certain positions.
An overriding concern voiced by council members Brad Bolton and Mike Kennedy was that with the new understanding of which employees the council has a say on and which they don’t, that the council has little, if any sway on personnel matters.
Councilman Brad Bolton had requested the special called meeting to hash out concerns that the council’s wishes had seemingly been ignored by Fancher in the termination of former operations director Mike Shewbart, who was fired from the post on September 18. Bolton also cited the previous hire of a sewer department employee wherein he said Fancher “circumvented the Council,” in making the hire.
City Attorney Roger Bedford discussed with the Council at length and in copies of legal precedent presented to the board that Fancher had the legal right to hire and terminate city employees not covered by ordinance when there is just cause, and did not have to seek the Council’s authorization or approval to do so.
“The mayor acted in effect as the CEO of the town, running the day-to-day affairs,” Bedford said. “The council itself, and you’ll see it set out a couple of times in here, doesn’t have the right to fire an employee. You don’t have the authority.
“The fact that the individual was hired by vote of the council is just a resolution supporting what the mayor has recommended,” Bedford said. “It’s not an ordinance. If it was an ordinance and that person was designated as an officer – and it sets out in here that not every employee can be an officer – but if you give one the authority over other employees and designate it that way, then you can create a position. But you can’t just say, ‘well, that employee is an officer.’ It takes an official ordinance that would have to be put on the agenda, debated any way you want to debate it, and then voted up or down.”
Currently the only posts covered by ordinance in the city are those of police chief, fire chief, city clerk, city attorney and city judge. Those positions require a vote by the Council for hiring and termination. Everyone else is considered a city employee, though, placing them under the authority of the mayor.
“Based on what we’ve got in front of us, I absolutely see where you (Bedford) found that the mayor has the right because we did not set it out by ordinance,” Bolton said. “But for this Council and future Councils, I strongly believe that’s got to change. These department heads need to be accountable to this Council, the rule and voice of the people.”
Shewbart discussed
Though the Council members avoided specifically mentioning Shewbart in most instances, it was clear his termination, after the board refused to approve Mayor Fancher’s action, was at the heart of the matter. Both members of the board and the mayor said the way the situation was handled showed a lack of respect for each other in the process.
In a lengthy address to Fancher, Bolton expressed concern over city policy and actions he felt could compromise the working relationship.
“Mayor, you and I have worked together for the past eight years, and the only thing we’ve disagreed on has been the street department,” Bolton said. “We’ve had strong disagreements about the street department, especially in the last couple of years. But, last meeting when you make your comments talking about we need to do communication, cooperation and teamwork – and I agree with that. I think that’s the hallmark and defines where we’ve come from together. And I say we’ve been together, at least three of us have been together for nine years. My issue with this whole thing is that there wasn’t communication, that we had a specific issue with this specific employee.
“If we go back to November of ’16 when we all took office, and we’re talking about particular department heads and stuff like that, I think it would have been clear that every department head would have been hired that first night except for the one in question. And so, with the Council’s input of doing the homework and investigations to clear that person’s name in November of ’16 and those weeks that led up to that afterwards that ultimately led to us hiring all of these people by resolution, which I interpreted to be that the intent of this Council was that we would have a say-so in the department heads, because that’s what we’ve always done. Fast forward and here we are now where we believe we should have input, and I do respect the separation of powers – the executive branch versus the legislative and judicial, I understand all that. But I do think the Council’s voice needs to be heard if we’re going to be the voice of the citizens. . . . The terminology is what really confuses me, because we have a report of officers that stands up here . . . and we’re told they are the officers that are reporting to us. Now suddenly they’re not officers. We didn’t do it by ordinance, and hey – me as a Council member, I failed the citizens of Red Bay by not doing enough investigation or homework to say, wait a minute, we need to appoint these as ordinances that we want to have a say in, because that’s the way it had been done. Resolutions had been fine until we hit a roadblock like this.
“Resolution, ordinance, intent are three different things. I think it’s clear that the intent of this Council was that we should have had an input in this. My particular role in this as a Street Department Committee . . . There is no mistake that we know there were some issues there as far as personality conflicts. Two administrations ago we set up this committee structure in a way that would benefit this town and that the Council would have a direct interaction with these employees, that the members of the Council can advocate for the employees for improvements for political purposes and, when we need it, disciplinary issues. I think that committee structure has worked extremely well for the time it has been put forth. However, in this particular instance, we didn’t follow our own policy of bringing the committee together. Was it required? No. But, has that been the practice and the precedent? Absolutely, yes. In fact, the Police Committee had an issue even over the summer with a police matter that the Police Committee was brought in, y’all were told of an issue, you handled it openly. And ultimately an employee left employment with the city with that role, being involved with that.”
Bolton also addressed concerns that he and Councilman Mike Kennedy refused to make a move against Shewbart.
“I’ve been told that Mike Kennedy and I just see (through) rose-colored glasses,” Bolton said. “But it’s not true. There was an issue back earlier this year that, as a member of the committee, we had the mayor’s back on something, and I just don’t believe that things have been handled in a way that has shown me that there was not (just) cause (in Shewbart’s termination). That was my ultimate issue.”
For her part, Fancher said she felt the Council had ignored her requests even prior to taking office to eliminate the position of operations director as she would be handling many of those duties and did not need the position as previous Mayor David Tiffin had.
“Brad, I want to add to what you said and do some clarification,” Facher said. “We all know that each mayor, and our discussion when we first took office, I explained and discussed that each mayor is different. Each mayor needs different people in different positions. And if y’all all remember I talked about that. And I think you would all agree that the park and rec position at one time was moved up to director of operations. And that was when David Tiffin became mayor. And if you remember in our first meeting I said, ‘I do not need this type of position.’ But yet that was never changed. I requested that I needed a street supervisor. Do you recall that? And that was not changed. And that went on all year.
“Back in the administration of David Tiffin, I was also included on the Budget Committee. I was not called. Well, I take that back, I probably was called one time in three years. I did not call for a special meeting or I didn’t get bent out of shape because the way I look at that is committees are advisory. I call upon y’all (the Council) for different things. But I respected David that if he needed me to be on the budget committee as I was assigned, he would call me. Or he would have asked me if there was a specific time we could meet to go over the budget. But he did not. And so, I asked for this to be changed, for the title of that position, but it was not. I did have the authority at the very beginning to make changes, but I did not. We all as the Council worked together. As I said before I worked eleven months with each department director. I’ve put measures in place to ensure good communications, and I have been fair to each and every employee. But when you’re in this position – and I hope you are one day – because this position of mayor and being the CEO of the day-to-day operations is totally different from your position. Totally. While it would have been wonderful if everything in this position could have worked out it would have been great with me. But as I said before, that position . . . and that was, you actually all recall, there was a situation that occurred and that person was suspended for a few days. I thought we had worked through that. We kept going on and going on, but it didn’t get better. When you didn’t put the request that I requested back in the fall of changing that position and their responsibilities, I don’t feel like you were working with me. I asked you to make a change and you did not. That position wasn’t changed as far as giving up duties. That position took on a higher pay scale at the time it was director of operations. But yet, when duties came off of that, the pay wasn’t changed. Is that correct?”
“No, his pay was not changed,” Bolton said. “If that was charged to me to do, I do not recall that at all. I do know that you made mention that you were going to take on more responsibilities, which you have.”
“But you were already assigned to the Street Committee when we discussed that,” Fancher said.
“That’s right. But I don’t recall me (being) supposed to change a job description or title because would the title not come back here or to you,” Bolton replied, “because I obviously didn’t have the authority to make any changes or recommendations for the employee.”
Kennedy said he didn’t remember the discussion, either.
“For the record I don’t remember being charged with that either,” Kennedy said, addressing Fancher. “You asked Brad and I specifically to change a title, but to me the bottom line is where we are, if we read the last ordinance passed in ’01, 11-08-01, it says, ‘It is the expressed desire of the Red Bay City Council for the Mayor and Council to work hand-in-hand to resolve any differences in hiring and firing of city personnel.’ And then it goes on in the last paragraph to say, ‘until such further action of the Red Bay City Council is deemed necessary.’ To me, that’s exactly where we are. You made the decision to fire an employee. The majority of the Council did not agree with it, that you had just cause, you didn’t have proper documentation. But it is what it is and where do we go from here, so when there’s an issue like this in the future that we don’t get into this quagmire we’re in now? That’s pretty much the bottom line.”
“I did have proper documentation,” Fancher said, speaking of the evidence she had presented to the Council in explaining her decision to fire Shewbart. “Now, it was not presented to you each time, but I did have proper documentation. “
“Well, that would have been the time to bring it up, when you were in there telling us you were going to fire him,” Kennedy said. “That’s when it ought to have been laid out on the line, when the majority of this council voted – you didn’t even get it to a vote. You got a motion but couldn’t even get it to a vote. So that should tell the citizens of Red Bay that this Council, this body does not believe it was handled right and there was proper documentation. There’s no other way to look at it.”
“I would hope, Mike, that the citizens of Red Bay are more concerned about the best interest of this city and that I made a good decision for this city based on job responsibility and what’s being done in that position,” Fancher said. “And I still stand by it today. And I will stand by it.”
Bolton then brought up the previous issue with a sewer department hire.
“You can’t look at stuff in a vacuum, and this is the second time that a decision that was very important for the city as far as an employee was dropped on the Council,” Bolton said. “The Council didn’t go along with the recommendation and it just went around us anyway. It’s hard for me, I think other Council members can speak for themselves. You can go back to the sewer employee that we asked not to be hired until more investigations could be done, if we needed that position, and so no decisions were supposed to be made and then we were circumvented around that. You used the sewer board to do it and then it comes to this one. It wasn’t supported in this decision because we didn’t feel like you had the documentation in order. And so the only way that we’re going to move forward is . . . .” Bolton said, trailing off without completing what was on his mind.
“Well, like I said, until you’re involved in the day-to-day operations, it’s all about the details,” Fancher said. “That’s just all there is to it Brad. I believe some of you have seen afterwards, some of you who are on boards, even more so after this (Shewbart’s termination) has taken place, I know more and more it’s right because I’m having to fix a lot of situations that’s been requested for years that have not been completed.”
Fancher voiced frustration over the lack of a public show of support by some on the Council for her decision to terminate Shewbart.
“I know a couple of you, when we’re not at Council meetings, you say, ‘well, you know the truth,’ and ‘I believe you did the right thing; this thing was never going to work out from the very beginning,’” Fancher said. “But no one speaks up. That’s OK.”
Employees first
Kennedy said his primary concern was that with the board’s new understanding of the law, it appeared city employees would have no recourse in the event of a firing.
“Let me ask you this, from an employee standpoint,” Kennedy said in questioning Bedford. “I’m not talking about director of operations, just an employee. The way it is now, the mayor is like a sole proprietor, they can hire and fire at random.”
“A general rule of thumb to think of on this is the authority that hires the person has the authority to terminate a person,” Bedford said. “But it needs to be for cause. I can’t just come in and fire you because you’re wearing an Auburn shirt and I’m an Alabama fan.”
“I understand that,” Kennedy said. “But what I’m saying is there’s no buffer that can be created for an employee.”
“You could create a personnel policy or a civil service board that someone could appeal a termination to,” Bedford said.
The problem with going to a civil service board, though, as Councilman Jason Vinson pointed out, is that a civil service board would take away all hiring and firing input from both the mayor and the council.
“I’m only saying this,” Kennedy said. “In the future you could get a mayor and a street employee, and they have children the same age, and he’s bullying the mayor’s son or whatever, and the mayor takes it out on the employee and just fires him. And if there’s not something in place, civil service board or some recourse, they can just . . . . I’m not saying that would ever happen; I’m just saying that’s a possibility.”
Bedford, however, reiterated that the mayor, though having full rights to hire and fire employees, would have to follow certain guidelines.
“The mayor, in my opinion, could not fire someone without cause,” Bedford said. “I need to research that a little bit more, but you can’t just fire an employee because you don’t like them. We are an at-will state. I can fire somebody in my office or you can fire somebody at the bank just because the Auburn-Alabama thing. But the employee who thought they were wrongfully terminated could go to court over it.”
“Well, they’ve always got that right,” Kennedy said, “but you know as well as I do that’s expensive and most employees can’t afford to do something like that to start with. I’m just asking; I’m just seeing what’s potentially out there.”
Moving forward
With an obvious rift among the mayor and Council over the firing of Shewbart and the sudden realization that the Council has little or no say on most personnel matters, Council members said they hoped they could establish more positions as covered by ordinance to give them more say, and they also hoped to be able to work together in unity.
“I think that we can all agree that six people sitting up here with differing backgrounds, different experience and different skill sets, that’s what makes us as a coalition group good,” Bolton said. “I hope we can move forward, too, mayor, but (that) our opinions will be heard on it because those two instances, I just don’t think, differing background and skills has been listened to or heard.”
“God makes us all different, special and unique,” Bedford added. “Brad said you could communicate and cooperate, and that’s the best environment for everybody. Just because you differ over an opinion – you see that (in other governmental bodies). That doesn’t have to be a bad thing. That can be something you learn from and you get a better understanding and a lot of times, just as you said just because something’s been done that way you do it that way. But then that’s why you have laws and that’s why you have the Supreme Court cases and stuff. Because at some point in time somebody else got crossed up on it and they found out what the law was and that applies to everybody.”
Vinson expressed his belief that the Council coming to an understanding of the law was a good thing and couple potentially be positive for the city.
“I respect every individual up here and their background,” Vinson said. “And I think together, collectively, it’s going to be a good thing once all this stuff is ironed out about these situations and what needs to happen. I think there will be a lot of progress to be made, moving forward. A lot has already been done and a lot is still coming forward.”
Councilman Jarod Massey discussed the possibility of establishing better guidelines on documentation requirements in the city’s policy manual, and Fancher and Bedford both said the Council could make those changes there without a problem.
Bolton asked for a motion to request Bedford investigate how other cities of similar size handle the positions of court clerk, revenue clerk, parks and recreation director and street supervisor. Council members had previously asked Bedford if positions could be created by ordinance but left unfilled should the council decided that position was not needed. He said the argument could be made that they didn’t have to be filled, but the argument could also be made that if the position was important enough to warrant being called a city officer and being in a supervisory position, the argument could be made that the position should be filled.
The Council approved Bolton’s request, and Bedford is expected to present his finding at a future Council meeting.





